Skip to content

How to BE A MAN: essential and performative masculinity

Channel: Orion Taraban
Video: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=92z27GM0BnE

The speaker's core claim: real masculinity is not a performance of manly behaviors but two essential qualities, a "spine" and "balls" (figuratively): knowing what you believe and being willing to risk everything for it.

Key points

  • Modern men face an identity crisis; a century ago "how to be a man" would have been a ludicrous question because the answer was assumed known.
  • Performative masculinity: most internet answers (grow a beard, lift, start a business, hunt, fight, grill, drink whiskey, etc.) define manhood as a suite of behaviors, props, and postures. Like femininity, these are learned performances tied to a time and place, signaling status, not natural.
  • The speaker says he is not performatively masculine (works with words in a "feminized profession") yet considers himself extremely masculine, because manhood reduces to two things.
  • A spine: willingness to stand up for what you believe is true, which is who you are. This presupposes knowing your values, which most people do not, since much of what is in their heads was put there by others. Young men get a pass; many older men still do not know their values.
  • Standing up casts a "shadow": declaring who you are necessarily attracts opposition, disapproval, even people who want to destroy you, and the taller you stand the more so. The alternative (spinelessness) means never knowing who you are.
  • Balls: willingness to suffer the risk of being a specific individual, putting money, relationships, career, reputation, even life on the line for what you believe, and not caring whether others approve.
  • A spine without balls means a life spent hiding from friends, women, and yourself.
  • You cannot force respect, but a spine plus balls raises the odds of earning it. Paradoxically we respect those who do not seem to care whether we like them, and withhold respect from those who act in order to be liked.
  • Conclusion: with the right values and the willingness to risk all for them you are a man, regardless of beard, sports, drinking, or sexual conquests; without them, the trappings do not make you one.

Reception

  • Strongly positive; commenters praise the clarity and concision and treat the spine/balls framing as a definition worth keeping.
  • The most-liked comments distill or reframe the message: "spine = courage to say No, balls = courage to say Yes," and the idea that being a man reduces to taking "responsibility" for oneself and then widening that circle.
  • Many shared personal testimony: men raised by single mothers saying they never learned manhood and want a role model, a son recounting a courageous WW2-veteran father, and several resolving to stop hiding their true selves.
  • A recurring practical theme is the value of saying "no" and not fearing conflict; one long, highly-liked comment urges young men to stand up at work and in family even at the cost of jobs or friends.
  • Some added their own criteria, such as self-control, discomfort for the sake of growth, and the ability to protect oneself and loved ones; one noted the role of healthy testosterone (sleep, exercise, avoiding hormone disruptors).