Skip to content

Talking with an Incel about Starting a Relationship

Channel: HealthyGamerGG
Video: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=MPnWbj70TTY

A live-stream session with "Paul," a 35-year-old Londoner who has never had a girlfriend. Dr K argues the barrier is not Paul's looks or tactics but a deep, protective hopelessness ("I cannot be helped") that other people sense and that sabotages every attempt.

Key points

Reframing the "incel" label

  • Paul applied under the term "incel" as attention-grab but rejects the misogyny/ideology attached to it; he just means the literal "involuntarily celibate" - never had a girlfriend, cannot seem to change it.
  • Dr K's stance: he does not treat classes of people (gamers, execs, incels) as having class-wide problems - only individuals with individual issues. He is not a dating expert; his expertise is how the mind works.

The core belief: "I can't be helped"

  • Paul opens by asking whether Dr K can even help him - which Dr K reads not as neutral skepticism but as fear rooted in a belief that he is hopeless.
  • Supporting "evidence" Paul cites: four bad NHS trainee therapists (no continuity, one forgot his one burning request), and a paid CBT therapist who, 5-6 years ago, effectively gave up on him ("don't pay me, I won't see you again"). Dr K reframes this as an expert wrongly signaling Paul is hopeless, which reinforced the belief.

Cognitive bias as the mechanism

  • Dr K's central diagnosis: instead of using new data to update his interpretation, Paul uses his interpretation to reshape the data - when a conclusion contradicts "I'm hopeless," his mind scans memory for more supporting evidence. Illustrated with the "boss yells at me for being late" example (ego justifies rather than updates).
  • Because Paul is intelligent, the bias is stronger, not weaker: high IQ produces more forceful logical arguments and evidence for the doomed conclusion. Cognitive bias "hijacks your IQ."
  • Dr K repeatedly catches Paul doing this in real time (the "duration of the experiment," "it's evidence-based," the statistical "some people are meant to be alone" thought loop).

Protective hopelessness

  • Giving up is comforting: if Paul accepts he can never have a relationship, he no longer rides the rollercoaster of hope, rejection, and hurt. Loneliness he can live with; hope followed by a smack in the face he cannot.
  • His external fixes (losing 10-15 kg, new clothes, bars, clubs, a dozen speed-dating events) all failed - Dr K's point: if a thousand external solutions fail, the diagnosis is wrong; the problem is internal.
  • Key distinction Paul surfaces himself: he succeeds professionally (career in London despite a rough start) because he believes he can, but fails romantically because he believes he can't. The adversity in his work history that crushed him actually came from a woman (a workplace relationship that got him fired), not the job - same underlying problem.

The intervention: awareness precedes control

  • Frameworks named: CBT (therapist as a mirror for your own thoughts), meditation as "stepping back from the mind," alexithymia (Paul's poor memory for and suppression of emotions), and "samskaras" (sum scars) - dormant patterns that activate and, when active, feel like absolute truth.
  • Core move: create distance between self and thought. "I will be alone for the rest of my life" (absolute) vs "My mind believes I will be alone for the rest of my life" (a thought). The mind is not the knower of truth.
  • Practical assignment: before and during speed-dating, notice the hopelessness and laugh in its face. Paul does briefly break into an unburdened laugh/cry mid-session; Dr K holds this up as proof he can do it and that an unburdened person is what women are actually attracted to (people sense whether you are carefree or burdened).
  • Dr K declines to teach meditation this session (Paul is too emotionally raw) but suggests alternate-nostril breathing, noting you need not believe in it - like drinking water produces urine, doing it works regardless.
  • Closing (karma/phala): action vs fruit. Society fixates on the outcome (the A, the girlfriend, the stock price); focus instead on the action in the present. Don't aim at "get a girlfriend," aim at working on yourself and releasing the hopelessness. Dr K cites his own 140 medical-school rejections over three years as the model of acting despite despair.

Reception

  • Overwhelmingly warm toward Paul. The top comments celebrate his bravery in airing his "dirty laundry" to thousands of viewers after so many bad prior experiences ("big ol cojones," "absolute legend").
  • Many viewers found Paul painfully relatable - his over-analysis, defensiveness, and negative self-talk mirrored their own, even for people whose hopelessness is not about dating ("he sounds exactly like my self talk").
  • A recurring read: Paul is in "an abusive relationship with himself," attached to hating himself, and doesn't need a woman so much as to learn to love himself. Several noted he visibly flinches whenever Dr K agrees with or affirms him.
  • Strong reaction to the therapist who abandoned him ("one of the most devastating things I've ever heard"), plus praise for Paul giving therapy yet another chance.
  • Viewers admired Dr K's patience against Paul's defenses ("more powerful than the US military," "goalkeeper of every sentence"), and rebutted the "this is just common sense" crowd: the therapist's job is to illuminate the common sense a person has been burying, not to say something never said before.
  • Repeatedly cited moments: the "do we have enough time - to fix me" line reading as "he thinks something is fundamentally wrong with him," and the "48:03 drink of water" tactic that got Paul talking.