Skip to content

Yes, Avoidants Shut Down When They Fall in Love (Here's Why)

Channel: Guided Awareness
Video: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=MRl3UXDf6GQ

A therapist explains that avoidants (dismissive and fearful) pull away not because they don't care but because falling in love triggers old fears, and the shutdown is usually a temporary processing phase, not an exit.

Key points

  • Two types framed up front: dismissive avoidants grow up with indirect pressure (parents hard on them, high expectations, sometimes pedestaled) and a negative view of strong emotions; fearful avoidants more often have bullying, abuse, and more extreme neglect in their background, and are described as far more complex.
  • For both, emotions were coded as bad/unsafe growing up, so the ingrained response to overwhelming feelings is to shut down - they can't literally opt out of feelings, so they go distant while processing. Distance can last days to months; they often come back, and may never actually leave.

Six reasons they shut down

  • Overwhelmed by feelings for you - falling in love feels like weakness or loss of control; shutting down is the old default from when big emotions got reprimanded.
  • Pressure to give more - part of them wants to give more but fears it won't be enough or that you'll reprimand/judge them; those fears tangle with the love, so they withdraw to untangle them. More common with dismissive avoidants.
  • They love you and don't want it used against them - especially fearful avoidants, because people historically have used their feelings against them; this drives discomfort with vulnerability.
  • They're processing and deciding whether to commit further - taking space to think through next steps (marriage, moving faster, moving in). Often they return with stated expectations/needs; that's not rejection but prepping you for what a relationship with them looks like.
  • You've been asking for more lately - if requests are creating pressure, back off, rebuild rapport, re-ask when they're ready.

  • They correlate falling in love with getting hurt - subconsciously bracing for abandonment; common in fearful avoidants. Reassurance that they won't be hurt helps; the real source is usually childhood (a parent, an early bully), not the current partner.

  • Practical advice: when an avoidant states their needs, don't just comply silently - state your own needs back and ask to meet in the middle. Be patient (and expect patience in return), especially with fearful avoidants given the severity of their trauma.

  • The host says the audience skews fearful-avoidant and speaks from clinical calls; frames the content as educational. (Speaker is a practicing therapist and psychology doctoral student; presents attachment claims as their clinical framing, cites no specific studies.)

Reception

  • Broadly grateful and self-recognizing; several viewers say the video finally explains their own or a partner's shutdowns and long pauses, and praise the calm, non-rushed, non-demonizing tone.
  • A recurring pushback on the "needs" and "expectations" framing: some ask "aren't we responsible for our own needs?", while others counter that relationships involve interdependence and human connection is itself a need, so stating needs is just telling a partner how to navigate you.
  • Anxious-side commenters push back that avoidant inconsistency is what creates the pressure in the first place, that patience has limits, and that at some point a deadline and moving on is healthy; one top comment warns that being with an avoidant warps how you read all future signals - "just get out."
  • Multiple requests for the flip side: more content on how avoidants can heal themselves rather than being discussed "as if they're not in the room," and a deep-dive on the childhood traumas that create avoidance.
  • Long anecdotal threads of readers narrating on-off dynamics, discards, and boundary standoffs; a common note is to judge by actions not words ("words are a magic trick," breadcrumbing gives false hope).