Skip to content

Coach Red Pill - The Best Man Rarely Wins

Channel: CRP Archive
Video: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=YIkmJopqMpE

A monologue arguing that the belief that the best or most decent man wins is an illusion; in reality success goes to the strongest, fastest, or most ruthless, and men must accept this to avoid ending up bitter.

Key points

  • We grow up believing the best man wins, both morally and in ability, because movies and stories show good triumphing over evil. The speaker calls this a comforting lie.
  • In reality the best man rarely, if ever, wins. The winner is usually the one willing to cheat, trip up opponents, and do whatever is necessary to finish first.
  • The "best man wins" only in trivial, artificial contests like the 100-yard dash or a math test, and these cases are rare.
  • All of Western civilization is framed as a striving to build a society where the best man wins ("right makes might"), but the real rule is "might makes right" / the golden rule: those who have the gold make the rules.
  • Lance Armstrong is cited as the example: he doped to win seven Tours de France, his defense was that everyone else doped too, and we condemn him for getting caught rather than for cheating. Many cheaters are never caught and get lionized.
  • Business example: in the 1990s Apple had the better operating system but was near bankruptcy with about 5% market share, while Microsoft won by being bigger and playing the game harder. Life rewards the fastest, biggest, or most willing to cheat, not the best.
  • To succeed, a man must be willing to do distasteful and even outright evil things, applied carefully and deliberately ("like radiation, with lead-lined gloves").
  • Men who cling to the illusion that goodness and effort guarantee success often reach the end of their lives with nothing, bitter and resentful. Making peace with this reality early is better in the long run.

Reception

  • Strongly affirming and grief-toned; many comments are tributes ("Rest in peace," "the father we never had") reflecting that the video circulated after Lira's death.
  • Several older viewers say they wish they had learned this lesson decades earlier (in their teens, 20s, or 30s rather than 50s) and report having been "chewed up" as the good guy.
  • A recurring counterpoint redefines winning: some argue staying loyal to your values and self-respect matters more than success, citing Jesus's "in the world but not of the world" and the GULAG Archipelago.
  • Others push back that what he describes is "settling," not winning, and that you can set your own definition of success rather than enter corrupted contests.
  • A few add cultural references (Archer from Fate/Stay as a true-neutral figure, a Simpsons line on cheating).